The following text may have been generated by Optical Character Recognition, with varying degrees of accuracy. Reader beware!

_ "*W-"WW' . . T ", k; TAR', ? ' -_""x','T. , ,. , _ I " ' . w. u "IP' l _ - W..." ---..,..-H _ we..." " i a ""TE Acertainly was the intention No Guarantee Mile. . I i , the Government that the act "Can you ive us ' a ould apply to Ontario, "and in the there won't Sim. any 'Tlll?ngimUt orpinion of the Department of Justice ties?" asked Mr. 7 , , t eact does apply." Hon. Mr. Raney Mr. 1"h"1.tlf/id,'"ileitiu. asked l, declared that he personally was pre- to give a guarantee on h k Ii pared to stake his professional re- ---iuru ia'i'iiiiC1',')rC..Coi', all agile-E32583? putation on the declaration that the a lawsuit? ' ' (act did apply to Ontario, irrespec- ' Referring to the amendment pro- I toi/eg/tit/ICT/tttion made of the sale 039 It . t i , . ' r; . I r -. I . annex sash] that 1////"fT2i,ig"'sin/)'orr,'" At Elm?" length he quoted Mr. Eu- ducin t A l . ., y ,1.l gene at our of Montreal. whom he not L", h. "I13. 18'") watt evldentis l referred to as the most eminent law- lat] am] l'," With the CE'I'WC" of legls-i yer, not only of Quebec but of Can- H00" Ie/i If, l Rrlt, tew _P'avs! ada, and of high rankIeven among Gi flee "f T,"), It (rovcrnment ""l legal gentlemen of the Old Coun.. .meu PLO." ,In' 191," which WT"? that: try. Later he declined to compare st . iminte Iarl.no jurisdiction ml 'the standing of Mr. J. w. Ewart of . opplng importation of liquor. He: lOttawa with that of Mr Lafleur Mr i"??? f" 'lay Mir James 1yh1neyi' _ vliwart. who had differed from. Mr: 'd', 'l)',","),',','),' effect. and the late lion, janet/r, was a man of recognized I'A 1'yla, fig"? in 1916. I ficgal standing, but comparison would I it? wt' h) this amendment be- he invidious I ing ittvlted to get onto dangerou-'il I 's. é _ ground----gwound which Sir James! ':Quotes,' Federal Minister. '. Whitney said in 1912 and lion. Mini I i Hanna. said in 1916 was dangerous! ' The Attorney-General read a new-g 53""??? In "323." those rv%uvk.sl "iUi,Cft1r,"1ui1gil,'ir"JiatVpet.d,1,oi1,i ii? is sutures at Wts should 'im--I ' ", ' I SQ Q h' .e I hark again on " doubtful "Hugo." Federal Union Government. It saidzg ' "div has tho honorable member who i,' C'? am of the opinion tlat Bf'1.2§i ititiudiiccd thriittivndmetat not told! 'i)ieliis, to thc Frmi'nce 1',C.,or)/,'cy,",ie: f . ii: y/yy could bo passed that thoI 7 he Attorney -(.ene al's. own departcz 'f"'""." has not PM" or Itropos-l "",pot 'J,'1',1/'Jitth1tc"'sidienc, native), " o pass?" 3 , s " "i i, Wino, Mr. Raney believed. would be! Taken (hit of Politics. F vliardly justified so soon after the peo- _ _ ... . . ' pie had pronounced on the Ontario; Ho 'i".'.?.?:") to Ilto i'iinmsnmn ho- Temperance Act, which embodied; N cause l "as i?,U,',.11y.1r",,"s.' " private the. exception to native wine sale,,: mmnbiii as . childish. lie argued! Any alteration affecting matters of', that tr.". qucstion had been taken out _ enforcement. the speaker said, would , of politics, and therefore should be be quite readily made, but great cau- . introduced by 1,r"u.v.it.t" member. It) tion would be used in making) ' was take-n out ot politics in 1916, he changes affecting fundamentals " said. .lic gave the Liberal party of the O.T.A. If Bill 26 were adopted; that time much credit for it. by the people, conditions would re-f Mr. Price il'arkrlale) asked it' it turn to those prior to January I. . was not because Sir William Hearst He, turned to the responsible Gov-g had. intrlodui-etit t3: ll'lt'lnsurt'. stuck 'i'i'/J'."t'll times: " his:I ',1,','rittii lie; to it an. saw 1 rouge. ea ct, icy ave. any on n ten "That was the culmination; and minds as to whether this is a. re-l not the starting," replied the Attor- Sponslhlc Government or not. letE ney-Gcncial. amid Liberal and Gov- them move a, vote of want of cone i-rnment applause. Ho t'nt'tationed tho dence." . : . iilytiisll-th".-rrur campaign, and the All tho rest of the VProvinces were', Liberal attitude thon and tho Con-l voting on the hill. iN hy should On-: . semativi- attitude, including- thei tario plow " . loner, furrow and do; member for Northwest Toronto. I something different? , Hon. yc,Cvyvfr'rt.! aro<e to make Ramsden for Bmckln Move. ' a few remai'n's. but. after. ms opening , M , ,' ' statement that "the Liberals worm l, :81):- /; f) lieang'ldl Jie/d2wt'iilt, H. " .0 . , b Pl o ST, , I, _ not ninceve. "g dron nod out I?) , tl,',.',"],',,".,,", ahiendment He Was a total , Lihcral' andl F'artuct. members. I'll 'al);taincx: and in favor of 111' legisla ironica aPPlatlse. i 'l. s " ' "t J., (I , . '." "it would "avts liecn against the: [tion to help the cause of (',r."11,i,1,",i.,-. trend of events of the past four years. in?" There 1vas "e. assurance, IIT: it the Govt-ont. had taken upon! fir/'1'. mfg if rtr1teha1ettJese/'//gn,tw,tg " use" it; {ntrold'um this measure"! [:3 2221201132" H: was igut'axlror if contiiiuec . r. CHney. b-'. _ C., Mr. Rant-f defended Mr. Rowen. IZuigfa'a't'd":":'iqgu'L0m;.LEI'Lnte'd to be saying that to was as much respon- I _. ' .'f _ C . mi . ' ' . John O Neill (Southeast Toronto) ,7 'i'elers,f/'r the peform as Sir 1Villiam said he would vote for the Brackin . Mr. iiiiiiiw r"/J"i'/.'; to Pursue his! T 'I',:'.'?:',,',,,'",',:,,.,,'),';.,';';',"), tll,'tt, leant'. former t emc. e gave Mr. Rowan . F "br- _ _., y. * , " , t . credit, hut tcaid his followers were not t1)i1utlda/"/'Ci,i,l)i,ytr "153133335 i333 , sincere. ""!". '.', L-.,] l, x, "cyc.1cm.re . ', Mr. Raney said that with_the going 'r'cryi1n,,1"fto111)oe1iti'"?t 1i'('1'1"tt"'i,ei, I' i _of the barrow" two-thirds of the more general and more liberal 56t- [ trouble had Bone. for the. workingman. There could " |Ottawa Government Not toBlamo. be no measure better than one sub-' . , . .. , mitted to the people. on the question: i oncecdmg, the Attor nev-Crcnorn', _ of beer and wine. But as there was;' declared he did not exactly blame the i 'v"ld'"i'e.11tte,", 11k: (that he could only 1 Ottawa Government for the defectsl vo 9. or: I-'.' fin?" mom. .. ; m Bill 26. "The friends ot the liquor: Dr. Embea Gotiftts (West York) ; tl:'ilai"ri'c',',, ho said "made all tlicvtroubleI said he Was not in favor of a refer-' they could for it in the House of' endum, and would only support the; Commons, and particularly in the! "ill '"s"/.'"fe,'iyii, (Frontenac) sa'd: 21031310. and the hill came throughi that. lining" the Jamendment " 1:6 i'enr ess on crutches." ". Il . '.t a . l f , ' . ' ' Mr. Dewart interrupted to ask if' . . ll otild vote rm the ttsolution. I [:6 temperance people had asked tor, . Present Position Impossible. i 2.'s',,ta',,, ") 2att. form. i'Mr' Haney; The Provincial Secretarv Hon H i I a bill ';f'dl"1utivgl1y't,,astt/i1oeilri" C. Nikon, declared that the Ii,iif.ir'll $1!er in; 51mm g', prohibit importa-i JU;?,),,?,)',','"" tfJ,1t5p'r.at £311??? 0:)"; ' n (I Ncr t o I _ , I . . . ' - Mr Mat-Bride (BI? tf f referendum. tiiiuation of the "present impossible; . ran 0rd) also-sought ' . "H Mr Ni aid tl I l Attorney-General added that the cosh O T231", increased On 3:8: I 2r'"/',e,ft?gyti.cpy1o, did not seek Fed- (She: land elimination of in'terproe I - u l we . , _ l . - ireasons; first 'tUi'lia/1T"ptiat1,etT,', vinciai trade would greatly 'ss'i"i'ca1'irsil , . , , '. . 1-; f , the d artme . I 3:812:53? tfirgImmmf people realized mat,erire//1'hlf/' adage \vasnconclusive i . r M . l F decide and one or it)!" pfsoplts to evidence as to the applicability oti i l.' '. "f ilu/Cf,",',,",',' t at the .Pro- Bill 26 to the Province of Ontario l lamina Sue. ',',ahaf,'. always tttood in It would be "an 'unwarranted insult' I? KF% th" '." . l ,issue 5. 1ts'e in regard to the orrthe Federal Government" for the I . w" _ rineet take st . _ l He. proceeded to discuss the vari- J2f,')f,11t C301,; a ated case to that Inns lei?! opinions which have been "I believe this is the only ulti-I (,'l/U',utlonel'.t aosfkeT'h.eft,3trht, Cfntgo- mate solution of the problem," hel. lieved Bill. iii",. a lie: ty th "i, e- declared. "I appeal to honorable! " f , "d . DD o f Tc members of this House to give this $1:in o. ( ntario. declared, I do." resolution a good send-off Surely of "t'iee"rJef/tuouot',t 1t,eah2,ta'tt,i,d,: it has had hard sledding, prGdisii', He read Hon Mr N w Ro'well'. because of the lobbying of interests letter of March 8.to 1hTsl?gG'di't' who we would t351?ect to he hehindi . ...of the., Dominion Alliance. declaring tttdeft',);,?.',',' mm everrounce _otl ' ' ' , I The House adjourned at ll O'OIOck. I M _.» - .. ",rr "t ' 2