Tots Trip To Kindergarten |Hands- Off Attitude Taken Referred To Supreme Court In Ottawa To Que. Voting By DON, MacLACHLAN REGINA (CP)--Ingrid Bint- lished a separate schoul.., all ratepayers of the same fre- ligious denomination in. the dis- board says it has not considered doing so. in Mr, Bintner's cas¢ There are two areas in Sas ner is a-brown-eyed five-year-'trict are bound to contribute to katchewan where non-Catholic old who had the Grade 2 reader licked when she was four, Her parents decided she was bored sitting at home and wanted her to go to kindergarten. Ingrid probably doesn't care but her Roman Catholic father | wanted her to go to public school kindergarten. Last July, the Regina public school hoard, to which he pays taxes, refused to enrol. her. The Supreme Court of Canada upheld the de- 4q cision... The board cited the School) Act of 1905 and a 1916 Privy|the Council ruling that Roman Cath- olics must support the separate schools in their area. If Ingrid' was to go.to achool, at all, it had to be a public school or a private kindergar- ten, The separate schoo! board operates no kindergartens here and has no plans for any at present, Education Minister George Trapp says the 1905 act and the Privy Council ruling mean that children of Catholic parents must attend a separate school, He says no one enforced the law until 1964 when Regina school accommodation became strained, -- Previously, the Regina board allowed Catholic children from separate school areas to attend public elementary schools as long as their parents were pay- ing public school taxes BAYS LAW 'ANTIQUATED' Bernard J. Bintner stopped paying separate school taxes in 1958 and has paid public. school taxes ever since. When the board made its ruling, four of his children were allowed to re- main in public schools Ingrid was the second Catho- lic child refused admission to public school kindergarten, Mr. Bintner, a prosperous oil com- pany manager, says he spent several thousand dollars in his court battle to have her en- rolled, The 52-year-old former high school teacher says the law is antiquated, Unless it is changed, he says, he'll send Ingrid to private school, "even if I have to create one myself."" She now is in private kindergarten The Privy Council, ruling in 1916 that a Regina Catholic could not transfer his taxes to the public school system from the separate schools (as Mr. Bintner was to do 42 years later), said: "Where the minority of rate- the support of stich schools." OBJECTS TO DICTATION Mr. Bintner maintains 'minorities have set up separate systems. Neither Quinton ' nor Gravelbourg, in a French-speak- 80" ing area, reports any problems ernment has no right to dictat® Sip the Jaw. which school a child should at- tend and complains that only Saskatchewan has such a law, Mr, Trapp says it has gained general acceptance Ingrid's father says his stand not opposition 'to separate -hools or their quality, nor a rre] with his church, but a beNef '"'governmént should be st people to enforce a church?s wishes," Mr. Bintner paid separate school taxes and sent his chil- dren to separate school until he moved to a house on fashion- able Calder Crescent in 1958, "I decided this was the time I could afford to make my stand," he said He started paying public school taxes and transferred his children to public schoo! Board chairman Alex'S. Coch rane says that in 1961 'we weren't happy about the con- stant demand for (Catholic) children to get in, particularly in kindergarten asked the education for guidance,' Allen FE is % 80 we department jlakeney, then edu- cation minister, wrote back say ing he interpreted the law, on the basis of the Privy Council decision, as ruling: 'The test is not one of.tax support but of religious allegiance." LAW* NOT ENFORCED The first enforcement of the law came in August, 1964, when L; Lepage tried to enrol his five-year-old son in kindergar ten, The public school board re fused, citing accommodation problems, Mr, Trapp says separate schools haven't tried to enforce | the Jaw in a bid to collect taxes from Catholics. The Regina Mr. Bintner says he can't un- rderstand why two of his nine 'children can be at public high school while Ingrid is denied admission to a public school kindergarten High school students are cove ered under the Secondary Fdu- cation Act, which _ provides parents can opt out of a sep- arate school district and pay publie school taxes for high school children Joseph P. Deiss, secretary- treasurer of the Regina sepa- rate school board, suggests the provision will disappear as sep- arate high schools are built; Mr, Trapp forecasts it will just be used less INJUNCTION BID FAILED No comment was available from church authorities but Mr Deiss says separate school board members,' although divided on the law, feel 'some sympathy for the few that are involved,"' School officials estimate there are perhaps 150 Catholic chil- dren still in public elementary schools here but could give no estimate of the number in pub lic high schools Mr. Bintner last applied for a Queen's court injunction preventing th public school board from deny ing admission to Ingrid. He was refused The bid was December Bench based on a sec tion of the Saskatchewan Bill of} Rights which says everyone hall enjoy education without | regard to "race, creed, religion, | color or ethnic or national ori gin."' Mr. Bintner then went to the| Saskatchewan Court of Appeal | Now ALC Furniture & Appliances 452 Simcoe St. S. Oshawa's New Furniture and Appliance Store feat- uring Admiral T.V., Zenith, top lines of furniture and anpliances, payers In a district have estab- THIS MESSAGE 6 SPONSORED BY THE KINSMEN CLUBS AND THE FOLLOWING BUSINESSES; BELL & BEAUCHAMP LTD. 524 Simeoe %, North 723-4661 DYL'S 166° Adeleide IGA Ave, ast MACKEY & -BAILEY Barristors and Solicitors OO Bere slt 000 Ferewe! Tony's Refreshment Servic OSHAWA T.V. SUPPLY LTD. Teunton Rd, Hest 728.8180 H, G, Roughley Insurance Ltd. 187 King St. Kost Cell 725-6588 HARDSAND LANDSCAPING 55 Glover &, 725-1721 H. KEITH LTD, REALTOR One of Canede's Oldest Reoltors -- Doug Carmichas! : Listings Urgently Required Coll 723-4763 181 Egiinten Ave, Fart RUSSELL TRANSPORT LTD. 246 Groburn 725.3559 Major Pool Equipment Ganada Ltd, 690 Drake $. 725-6582 WILLIAMS ELECTRONICS SALES & SERVICE 1218 Simeoe St, North 725.2908 ATTERSLEY TIRE SERVICE LTD, 227 Toronto St. 728.9432 HOWARD'S DRAPERIES 926 Simcoe St. North 725.3144 ANONYMOUS ANONYMOUS OPEN! AN 723-0011 Top Service and many este Seon, Pht pets es tee. By RONALD LEBEL OTTAWA (CP) -- Federal pol- iticians are keenly interested in the Quebee provincial election campaign hut most of them adopt a hands-off attitude Liberal informants say they will scrupulously observe the Quehec tradition of a clear sep- aration between provincial and federal politics at the oganiza tional leveb. Some Liberal MPs say privat- ely the government of Premier Jean Lesage is in trouble be- cause of stiff tax increases, pockets of unemployment, de pressed farm prices and an at tractive new platform featured by the Union Nationale. But other Liberals deny this saying Mr. Ie stock is high, A handful MPs with close friends among the provin- cial Liberal candidates are ex pected to campaign in their rid- ings , MAY REMAIN ALOOF The Progressive ye party has no official connections with the Union Nationale with the newly-formed Quebec Conservative parts Conserva tive MPs are expected to re- age's of Conservalt or which also refused the tion, In March he. un fully appealed to the Supreme Court Chief Justice @, M, Culliton of the provincial appeal court ruled that the public school pol icy did not constitute discrim ination as envisaged by the 1947 injune- uccess Bill of Rights, e main aloof from the campaign for the provincial election Sun- day, June 5 x f Clement Vincent, the. popular Conservative MPs who resigned his Nicolet - Yamaska federal seat to run as Union Nationale candidate in Nicolet, is consid- ered air isolated case, He had been thinking of entering pro- vincial polities for some time and his--federal-riding is--badly carved up in the new electoral man say they havé no intention of participating in the Quehec campaign in any way, They have no ties with the Quebec Socialist party, which is quasi- separatist Creditiste Leader Real Caou- ette said in an interview he has remained "completely re- moved" from the 'provincial rage so far and hopes this will continue.- But he might cam- paign later for the newly-formed ofher policies, Yollowed by So-\talks will tackle @ taz-sharing| THE OSHAWA TIMES, Mondey, Mey 9, 1966 7 cial Credit reforms. agreement for the next five Government leaders are|years, Both major parties in watching the Quebec campaign| Quebec are campaigning for a closely for indications of what\sharply-increased share of di- to expect from the Quebec de- rect taxes, legation at crucial federal-pro- vincial conferences in June and KEEP If STRAIGHT TRAINS DROP TAXES e MAIDSTONE, England en| RAINHAM, England (CP) The Kent Naturalists' Trust|Colin Brittain won a reduction . changed its name to the Kent\in local taxes because the rail- Trust for Nature Conservation|way intrudes on his privacy, next fall, FISH TRAUAS LABELS because would - be members|His home backs onto a railway The June 16-19 meeting in Vic-| In Ontario alone, the fresh|were confused, The president,|junction and he complained that toria will deal mainly with both|water hefring has three other|Lord Brahourne, expinined in-jpassengers stare into the win- touchy subjects in Quebec. names? sco, tullibee and gray-\dignantly, "They thought wejdows of the house when trains The fall federal - provincial! back. \ were a nudist elub,"" are stopped at the signals. Ralliement National, depending on "circumstances,"' HAS LOOSE ALLIANCE Le Ralliewfent National is a leaderiess alliance hetween| some Creditiste organizers and| a right-wing separatist group.| Its program calls for a provin- cial takeover of monetary and A. E. JOHNSON, 0.D. OPTOMETRIST 142 King St. East 723-2721 ANYONE FOR HOP SCOTCH? (BOAC offers you the fastest hop to Scotland) Steep yourself in the folklore of a bygone age, when Bonnie Prince Charlie roamed the glens. Find a piece of white heather, and luck will be yours forever, This year BOAC offers you the bonniest way to Scotland, Fly by magnificent Rolls-Royce 707 jet, and choose from 20 flights every week from Toronto to Glasgow. Like so many Canadians before you, discover the true warmth of a Scottish welcome, And chances are. you'll find yourself singing, "My Heart's in the Highlands".., And meaning it! All over the world BOAC takes good care of you ual BRITISH OVERSEAS AIRWAYS CORPORATION WITH AI® CANADA BOAC When we tell you this Volkswagen has sports car features like bucket seats, disc brakes, independent suspension, dual carburetors and a 4-speed floor shift, the last thing you expect isasquareback. fre 'WE NEW 1600 STATION WAGON SABYAN MOTOR SALES LTD. 334 Ritson Road South Tet: 723-3461 HELP FIGHT CYSTIC FIBROSI WHAT IS CYSTIC FIBROSIS? Cystic Fibrosis hits young kids in the lungs and in the digestive system --- claims more kids than polio ever did at its pre-vaccine worst. pel One in every.1,000 children are born with Cystic Fibrosis, it is now estimated. In the lungs, thick, gluey mucus clings to the inner walls, reducing the oxygen they get from the air they breathe. in the stomach, faulty digestive juices cannot extract the nutrition from the food they eat, HOW DOES YOUR MONEY HELP? The help care for these kids people - Canadian Cystic Fibrosis Foundation organizes projects like this one to earn money to -but more important --- with the aid of these public spirited its nationally recognized Medical Research Board uses your money to aid re- search projects. You - to find the actual cause of Cystic Fibrosis to find a cure or control for Cystic Fibrosis 'iH be Helping 'C.F.' Kids Right Here in this Area Give 'C, F.' Kids A Brighter Future ! ANNOUNCEMENT fo This Week Is The Oshawa Kinsmen Club CYSTIC FIBROSIS WEEK HELP THE KINSMEN CONQUER CYSTIC FIBROSIS The Oshawa Kinsmen Club are setting out to raise moriey or Cystic Fibrosis by selling chocolates and you can help this w derful cause, Buy chocolates from Kinsmen Club members or CALL 728-9494 THE KINSMEN CLUB WILL DELIVER CHOCOLATES RIGHT TO YOUR HOME, GIVE GENEROUSLY.