odourscrummy Winnipegdim mmlmim 16 if Walls Publisher HMoPhcraonMansgiog said Ed AssoCiationlCriticidl Much Of Cartierg Trix Report After an eight months study of the document the Canadian BarAasociation has found much to criticize in the Carter tax report The lawyers piobably would be overwhelmed wit the work of help ing clients make out their income tax formsgif the Carter royal commissions recommendations were to be made lnto law It is work they do not want Their opposition to many of the recommenda tions the CBAs annual meeting in Que bee was informed has been put in the form of brief and sent on to the Min ister of Finance Three of the Associa tions tax specialists summed up the main points of criticism Winnipeg lawyer Harold Buckwald ar gued that to succeed any new system of taxation must have public endorsement7 one essential that the Carter reportlacks The Carter report would create dull grey frustrating society in which area sight initiative sacriï¬ce and skill brought no reward but rather penaltiesf Mr Buchwald went on Through its redistribution of wealth features one finds unnecessarily extended expropr tions of personal property and acquISi No matter how the reports apologists seek to camouflage or gloss over cardinal facts and fundamental realities when the same property or event is taxed again and again in different eoples hands it is still double and pie and quad rupie taxation If there is economic merit in theCarter edifice the means to achieve it are too severe price to pay if you win prize in contest take it in cash At least you will have the funds to pay the tax on Toronto lawyer Ronald Robertson ar gued that the Carter reports idea of eguity seemed to be simply ability to pay ud when in doubt tax it and to hell with ancient distinctions about capital income gifts and so on Toronto lawyer Wolfe Goodman criti cized the reportis treatment of gifts and inheritances have no objectionto throwing the past overboard and starting afresh if can be convinced that the tradltional ap roach has not been very effective and at no amount of tinkering will improve the situation However in the field of taxation of gifts and inherit ances am by no means convinced that there is anything essentially won with our present system although mu like to see greater integration of gifts and estate taxes To includeglfts and inheritances in the comprehensive tax base does not meet even the vaguest cri teria of tax equity DOWN MEMORY LANE 20 YEARS AGO IN BARRIE Barrie thaminer Sept 25 1947 Elee tric power in town off six hours Sunday as carskidded on wet pavement of Bay field St into hydro pole Kempenfelt Bay now licensed as seaplane base Dr ltZD Grok Midhurst elected pr ident Centre Simcoe Conservatives with executive of Charles EvansBrad ford Colonel Garry Lee and Mrs Mercer Hamilton 331112 Rey noldselected president East End Home dc School Assoen Town Council adopted National Burl ing Code as basis new Barrie bylaw Inspector Peter ill Scott stated enrolment public schools in Centre Simcoe incrEaSed by 200 this term with eight new teachers Kiwanis Club held 25th anniversary party of Bar rie charter with dinnerdance at Club 79 arranged by Manager Keith Maybee Joe McNeiilie and his band provided music William Craig past president was master of ceremonies President Roy Christie presided at banquet Jack Stiver led singing with Lloyd Toff ord at piano Three former club song leaders were Gpresent to helpi Roy lticVittie of ueiph Ernie yen and Archie rWensley of Toronto Main speak ers were Walter Stewart Toronto dis trict governor of Kiwanis International and Charles Parsonsof Barrie divi sional lieutenantgovernan John ltlitchinson John Boys Robert son and Orville Todd named provisional committee to organize campaign for funds for new Barrie District Memorial Hospital Cecil Norris purchased Dundalk creamery Although Barrie plant of CGE in operation only two years Ernest Raycraft became first local member of companys Quarter Century Club Mayor Grant Mayor crowned Edna Carruthers of Stayner Miss Rural Simcoe at annual Farmers Dayspon sored by Barrie Chamber of Commerce Harrie Rota Club marked first anniversary Bill Blain elected pres ident Student Council Barrie Collegiate With Danny Macdonald pitching Penetan Arena 15 ale to win championshipplay ground softball league and Mrs Harry Armstrong won lawn howiin tourney at Allandale Earlscourt oung Peoples Silver Band from Toronto gave weekend concerts at Barrie salvation Army Citadel and town parks Hockey training began at Barrie Arena for Dallas Texans and Washington Lions EddieShore of Spring field is general supervrsor assisted by Art Chapman of Buffalo Bisons and Hap Emms of Barrie Junior Flyers Mrs Howden Barrie appointed area commissioner for Girl Guides of Ontario Arthur Harris returned from florists convention in Chicago OTHER EDITORS VIEWS CHARM OF RIDEAU CANAL LOCKS Ottawa Journal Part ofvthe summer charm of this area is the awareness of beauty spots to be visited when there is time People who take the chance to drive to the Mari times or the United States or who fly to Europe after saving like beavers have every intention of some day getting down the Rideau waterway to places such as Westport Newborn Chaffeys Locks and Jones Falls They are remminded of them by highway signs everr time they drive to Kingston and the Rideau district has reputation for attractive scenery Meanwhile the goodname and fame of the WestportJones Falls territory is well protected by Americans and visitors fromother parts of Canada holidaying IT we CANADA there recent traveller informs us He found in Westport New England at mosphere of courtesy although there were lots of young people about and he was pleased with the vignette of few ladies of mature years sitting at shelter drinking water from well They were tastingthe water as appreciativer as champagne expert would samplethe pro duct of good year Best Water in the World said large sign at the well and our reporterin his stuffy way said he hoped drivers of both cars and boats at vWESlPOIt would drink lots of what he called Adams ale Newboro has the first lock on the de scent from UpperRideau Lake to King ston and its lockkeepers now enjoy the convenience of having electrical power to open and close the gates cm my fay CANADAS IM ANTENNASARE useo on MAJsz SPACECRAFT AND safetiires Fl ANeio gmggLDEEmmguN dithARTLANDoF NAMEIZICA Ara one 0639 woman mgr EUROPEAN SitTL as STfLI ctuua PRECARfonLYlbnli aruunc Bonito mans saasa IWWND MZEflAMM NEAR momma pisscnrw ONTARle sarcasm COMMUNITYMlIEWlmtI n1 JUMNS rollvacuum Mauser 1mm mm nutcoco nrssrs sow525 moweramour 11$ Mrmz ms sco warm tionai indoor Street Polecats5beat Barrie Rockies yearly condemns Chicken Is MatIth un AWilllzsnuno Ky up urns election non unaware roaoyip If you cmt woo loom With words try dildos Chicken lsblg in this years Ontario election litany rtdings and all portion are holding corn points or picnics They are turning to these out door outlngs in an attempt to counter the lack of interest of Legal years in polldcnl meet Not that picnics In new in some riding they have always been used Bock inthe old days when the province was predominantly rural they were always campaign feature John llacdonaidfor exam gle was an ardent believer in cm hut Uils year we are seeing neat many of lheni not only in rural seats but in suburban tidings GIVING UP The politicians in fact are largely giving on tho tradl ltirnl mccinrt and particularlyI the man ral lics which used to provide an onion excitement it is justtoo hard these days Lt get crowd out And they nw that poor meeting is worse ihnnmo meeting at all Whicth onereason why we didnt see anyblg kickoff ral ties to start this campaign It has been the custom to fry and got out big crowd at mass rally when the leaders open their campaigns with their keynote speeches Thls your the Liberals and the NDP didnt even try this The Conservatives did stage rally in Hamilton for Premier Robaris opener but ihough BIBLE THOUGHT Now unto him that is able to do exceeding abundantly above all that we ask or think Iccordv log to the power thlt worknth in on Ephesians It The ability of God to do is lim ited only by our unwillingness to yield Without faith it is lmpnsr alble toplease Him Ya have not because yc ask not CANADAS STORY there were bands and cheer leaders and other hoe ll to try and get off Ioa rplr start the mectln wu pale in com partner to rise of other days There were some 700 people on hand but thus were repro lentfive ofcighl riding When youdcducted the paid up oy ees and campaign War era there were few of the general public on hand our ron roop lhs barbecues and picnics usually do get good turnouts nut politicklng has to be understand at them it Is felt that man with his mouth full of chicken is not good subject for long speeches He wants to AROUND Worn will China Stout Next World War plume time Foreign Affair Analyst IAmerican planes how in Vietnam to within seven miles of the Chinese binder Washing ton indicates it will bond Ir thin antibaltlstic against the possibility of Chlncsa attack VltlilhChlna violent convulsions continue In that the huge country often gives the impression of mad ness Ara all these their con nected Could China go colleclt tivcly so mad as to fool unbear ably provoked in her confronta tion with the 115 and launch world wart And what about American psychology in all thin The reasoning leading to answers for arch questions is intricate for instance Aracel oens say that it 13 perfectly Chm safe to bomb nonr the Chinese borderwhich means abnost inevitably that some US planes will cross that border the Chinese Mr Rusk assures us will nottry ooshart hour mucus is thick gully West Iournalisis Soyed Our fBuiialo 303 BQWMAN it seems incredible in this day and age but some ex eris believe that the Arncrcann were deliberately responsible for the buffalo becoming almost extinct in Canada Until the set tlement of the prairies began the buffalo were the most numerous large animal in the world Even in 1874 when the North West Police made their historic journey to Alber te Inspector Denny wrote flhera were places where far as the eye could reach untold thousands were in sight the country black with them Yet soon after the Blackfeet Indians signed Treaty Number at Blackfoot Crossing on the Bow River Sept 22 1877 the buffalo were so scarce that the Indians were reduced to eating gopher and field mice In 1573 Edgar Dewdney the lndian Commissioner reported that the buffalo had been driven across the border by series of prairie fires that had been started almost simultaneoule from Wood Mountain to the Then US Ge al Miles placed his army between the herds of buffalo and the border and prevented them from returning to Canada They were slaughtered by commercial interests and in loan the 05 112 idiotic Examiner no Balï¬eld Street Barrie Ontario Authorizesi as second class matter Post Office Departf ment mum and for pay ment of postage to cash Daily Sundays and Statutory Holidays excepted Subscription rates daily by carrier 45c weekly $1340 Sin is copies 10c By mail $2340 year Ontario $1200 ye motor throwoff s15 year Mail out side Ontario $14 year Out side Canada Br sh slam tis ye mm to ye National Advertisan Of fices 425 University Avenue Toronto 640 Cathcart Montreal 507 1200 West Pe der St Vancouver BC Member of the Canadian Daily Newspapmijubllshera Amoclatlon the Canadian Press and Audit Bureau of Circulations The Canadian Press is on oluslvelyjontltled to the use for republication of all news dispatches in his paper crad ited to it or The Assocated Press or Reuters and also the local news published werein three months Game Report announced that only six buffalo were known to be in existence PLAYED BIG PART No western newspapcrmen played big part in preventing the buffalo from becoming extinct Norman Luxton who had worked for the Calgary Herald and flienyfounded Town Topics in Vancouver suggested to lion Frank Oliver founder of the EdmontonBulietin that the Canadian government should buy privately owned herd of buffalo from Michael Pablo in Montana Oliver got the government to put up th money and the herd was dr en lo Wainwright now nati al park where the buffalo popu lotion is carefully controlled They should never become extinct but cannot roam tho plains again hoth Luxton and Oliver had remarkable Among many other adventures Luxton tried to paddle around the world in canoe but got only as far as Fiji althoughhis part ner Voss sailed all the way to London in threeyears and Frank Oliver came from Peel County in Ontario and ioilfed as typesetter for the Winni peg Frec Press in 1373 Then he drove an ox icart across the prairiesto Edmonton where he bought the first Int ever sold fi1ere for $25 In 1880 he issued the first edition of the Bulletin printed on hand press imported all the way from Philadelphia The first masthead for the apler was carved from birch ar OTHER SEPT72 EVENTS lashRobert ll arrived at Red Deer to begin service with Hudson Bay Com Filly 18514 capital of Canada ionHouse luf rn ii the Unemploymen Relief Act became the PltflNE 72mm mural aaamr ADDED srsniznvo DON inunnar ideal channel cttbcinmegctothepubtlc liflnlk wiu naive directions can Alill External Affairs Minister Paul East and report directly to Sec rs WRODHO chow chickch potpolitleal thoughts la the on type of amino lngrnosteniohuisllplnoedon inchstrains nioctlwofm thelendeu with local dignitar ies and mill paru groin and local press radio and tele vim These rhapl not be ported and reported one1 reporter at corderenco ukad Mr Robert if John Dietetic ker would be helping him But under fodayrcondltlonl they are the only approach available should America build an anti misslle defence against Chinese missllel lhat are not yet opera llonslf Washington believe that the Chinese will go tp war as soon as they have enough missiles What would cluno them to go to war The desire to liberate Fourteen the edits that us nuiltary presence In Sotnbcnst Asia is an unbearable threat and American violations of Chlncsn air apnea an intolerable provocation There are among the military those who want war with China to annihilate her before she develops her mililt tary strength further these men cannot bring themselvestn believe it will ever be possible to get along with strong They are net in control of American affairs but are occasionally in control of 115 forces near China and may tend to escalate some periph eral incident involving Chinese and American forces in the hope that an opportunity will thus be createdto destroy China These men one must repeat are not in control of LS affairs but they exist and thelr existence is known through their writings thelr speeches their private conversations Peking knows these Americans exist and that is one reason for the backbreaking struggle to produce modern weapons the sane 0an among the Chinese leadership want deterrent they want to make sure that the sane men in Washington will have good reason for keeping the warlike under control These are sane men on both sides and despite the current Chinese upheaval sane men still seem to control the policies of Peking that is why Hons Kong is allowed toaurvlve China needs the trade with Hong Kong and It lsya proof of sanity not toeut off oncl nose to spite ones face What does China want basically better standard of flying To this end she needs help which eventually must be from America It would be insane fortha Chinese to destroy the country from which they must get help eventA ually but the Americans and the Chinese both fear one another such fear gives the less lane opportunities to aggravate each small incident into major war Martin Backs Representative umrnn NATIONS or Martin of Canada said Friday he hopes the UN General Assem wnl transfer the Mid dleEas problem hack to the SecurityCounctl where it belongs He reiterated his siipport for thaappointrnent of UN repre sentative torso lathe Middle rotaryGeneral Thant in the absence of direct negotiations betxveen is al and the Arab state on the after math of the fiveday war in June this vouldat leaatprovtda an opportunity 3to form link between the two parties oNbv JANET LEIGH omen IXPWHON Vision conferences had his UPPSALA3wodan AP ihc Seismological lnalifutl the hue registered an underground gum which to explosion Friday in the Semina lree of Soviet central Soviet Union This usually underground nuclur test by the Maria is expected next Thursday to decide if bond will buctforltobsrtlsontbcmnn charged with tie producer flush OConnor the National Jilin Baird cl Claude had as waived In examine in trial Thursday before lath chcr Coin Judge Jslnu If Caudli was ordered heldJ without ball The hearing but week will determine if the retired sawmn operator all glble for hot and what flint ball should in mm mrmimvmwauraos PHONE mum Evangelist Bolt Mcturen of Guelph ll of Codrington Public Sclioo For Barrie areas entenninlv rusode For Christ Tonight Special Music 800 pm fGnlileun Quartet From Guelph Presented by Northside Bible Chapel SEE IT WITH SOMEONEYOU LOVEI RARE BEAUTIFULI THRILLINBI Man and WOMAN hither scion swam mum taunts rssuvu WIN SOLDEI ElOEE IAIN nu wontnu In in BARRI HURONlA DRIVEIN THEATRE srAarmcroMoaaowp tinuoum ricrunrs mum mutations nmwu LAST TIMES TONIGHT THE LOVE INS THE MYSTERY or Titus isLANb Munitions FuneralinBerlinra TECHNICDLORI FANAVIEIOHa Hmlffllflll GREAT Harp5553 musn tintsue dnnblo bill PLUS