THE CANADIAN STATESMAN, FEBRUARY 14,2001 PAGE 5 Auditor general slams 'intuitive approach' of nuclear standards A federal auditor has slapped die Canadian Nuclear Nuclear Safety Commission - the regulator which oversees nuclear facilities including the Darlington Generating Station - with a Iess-than- flattering review. Tuesday, federal auditor- general Denis Desautels released released his annual report on federal government spending. spending. In his report, he staled i'the monitoring of nuclear reactors reactors in Canada is largely ^performed with an "intuitive ^approach" rather than a systematic systematic use of standards. - The auditor-general's ^comments were welcomed jby Durham Nuclear Aware- mess (DNA), an industry Kvatchdog group based in .^Durham. ' Î "The auditor general's report report is accurate for as far as it ■goes," says DNA spokesman /Irene Kock. There's a lack of [objectivity for how stations fare rated for safety." The report report "shows how subjective /staff are", she says. From a [public safety standpoint, "It -points to an issue of assurances assurances everything is OK in ;the short-term," she says. > In his report, Mr. Desau- ftels stated, the CNSC's "reg- i'ulatory activities are not Abased on a rigorous, well- documented system of risk Analysis and the ratings it assigns assigns for regulatory perfor- •imance are not clear. It can- dot adequately demonstrate "that it is achieving its safety ^objectives for the regulation iof power reactors." I The CNSC uses ratings ÿf 'acceptable', 'conditionally 'conditionally acceptable' and 'unacceptable'. 'unacceptable'. The Darlington facility facility has an 'acceptable' rating. | "The criteria for what is 'acceptable or unacceptable tare subjective, which can lead to lack of understanding and agreement, both within CNSC and between CNSC and licensees, on the adequacy adequacy of safety performance," Mr. Desautels stated. And, the rating of conditionally conditionally acceptable "does not clarify whether and to what degree safety is being managed managed properly and if the licensee's licensee's action plans and progress are satisfactory." Clarifying and possibly expanding the ratings would "improve the consistency of interpretation" and be clearer for the public, the CNSC and licensees, the report stated. In an action plan posted on the CNSC Web site, the commission "agrees with the recommendations of the office office of the auditor general" and is taking steps to address them. "As part of an improved improved reporting of safety, we will consider the use of quantifiable safety ratings in the overall risk assessment." The CNSC agreed the acceptable, acceptable, conditionally acceptable acceptable and unacceptable rankings "need to be clarified clarified to enable consistent application application and effective communication communication of licensees' overall safely performance. 1 A review of the use of these rankings has already been initiated" and should be finished finished by August of this year and in use by the end of the year. "The CNSC has exercised exercised effective regulatory oversight of its licensees-for many years," the site states. Ms. Kock suggests the auditor didn't go "far enough in dealing with the culture of the industry". She noted those working for the regulator regulator are recruited from the industry. industry. "The culture of the regulator, regulator, it has an aspect of not being arm's-length enough from the industry. It comes from being in the industry," she said. During recent hearings in Pickering on an environmental environmental assessment to restait the four shut down reactors, municipalities municipalities noted the regula tor and utilities are too close, she points out. "Who the regulator appoints is loo lax. There needs to be some adjustment adjustment so there's a better, more responsive relationship between the regulator and utility," Ms. Kock adds. The auditor also noted the CNSC is having difficulty filling vacancies because staff are reaching reaching retirement age and the commission commission can't match private-sector salaries. While saying "there's no easy solution" to filling vacancies. Ms. Kock says. "We don't want to see recruitment from the industry." Instead, the industry should contribute money to train people, she states. "There arc ways to ensure the funding goes through and it still re sults in an arm's-length relation-, ship," she says. "The money has to come from somewhere. There's a lack of resources for the nuclear, regulator to do its job. We favour the industry paying a bigger bill for the regulator to do its job." ; Myrtle Beach 10 days from $699 j From February until May, departing Tuesdays. 11-800-668-6859 ' Price per person twin inch GST We Now Store Photos on CDs! $099 24 or 36 Exposure for only O Ready in ONE HOUR or Next Day! (picture processing is extra) éPt* tConica ILINE PHOTO 1300 KING ST. E, (K1NGSWAY VILLAGE) 723-8867 Oshawa's Largest International PSYCHIC FAIR READERS BOOKS, CRYSTALS FREE LECTURES AND DËMOS Friday: 12-10 pm Saturday: 11-10 pm Sunday: 11-7 pm Admission $6 GOOD ALL WEEKEND çünBiïs CAàir RAM/ Youth Strategic trategy jeunesse Employment f emploi Strate - * Summer Jobs IMPORTANT NOTICE To Employers Summer Career Placements is a wage subsidy program that enables employers to hire students during the summer. Private, public and not-for-profit employers are invited to submit their application by: March 30, 2001* As the objective of the program is to provide provide students with work experience related to their field of study, applications will be evaluated based on the quality of the experience offered and local priorities. To apply or to find out more about this program, please contact your nearest Human Resources Development Canada office or call 1 800 935-5555. Internet: www.hrdc-drhc.gc.ca * Please note that the application deadline for the Northwest Territories and Nunavut is April 6, 2001. Open Every Saturday & Sunday |^| Human Resources Développement des IT I Development Canada ressources humaines Canada ^ Canada Diamonds are a 1 -'dbivAil Win a pair of diamond earrings for the one you love! February is... FREE family karaoke month! weekends 11 am to 4 pm Enjoy FREE family breakfast bingo! from 9:30 am to 10:45 pm Next Month... Home & Carden Show March 2nd, 3rd, & 4th Joshua Morrow of Y & R appearing March 10th, 3 pm Don't miss March 25th - hip-hop group Untamed performs hits from their new CD! Flea Market • Farmer's Market • Antique Market • Warehouse Sales • Entertainment www.pickeringmarkets.com The Pickering Markets METRO EAST TRADE CENTRE . . . Never a dull moment! ;'.Yr Vt ; • SSSBIÉ- 2001 Pontiac Sunfire Sedan SIX 48 MONTH SmamU/m 48 MONTH Smari Lease SZI8" ib 5 26Z' $1,999 down payment, $0 down payment, ' $730 freight and $300 $730 freight and $300 security deposit required security deposit required LEASE RATE % up to 48 months* PURCHASE FINANCING )% up to 60 months 1 5- Year 100,000 km Powertrain Warranty 4-Speed Automatic Transmission with Traction Assist Air Conditioning Remote Keyless Entry Power Door Locks 6- Speaker CD Stereo 2001 Pontiac Grand Am SE Sedan 48 MONTH SuariLease 48 MONTH SmariIiase S Z68' $2,250 down payment, $0 down payment, $795 freight and $325 $795 freight and $375 security deposit required security deposit required OR PURCHASE FINANCING Z.9 % OR up to 36 months 1 826 $0 down pa $795 fieigh security dep CASH PURCHASE 49,998 excludes freight ol $795 February 16,17,18 Kinsmen Club, 109 Colborne St. W. (at McMillan) www.PsychicExpos.com for FREE stuff! | 2001 Buick Century Custom 2.4 Litre Twin Cam 150 HP Engine 4-Speed Automatic Transmission with Enhanced Traction System 4-Wheel Anti-Lock Braking System 4-Wheel Independent Suspension Air Conditioning Power Door Locks CHOOSE 2-DOOR OR 4 48 MONTH SmariLcasc 48 MONTH SvamUase S Z98" or 8/7' OR $3,400 down payment, $895 freight and $350 security deposit required PURCHASE FINANCING )% $0 down payment. $895 freight and $450 security deposit required PURCHASE PRICE 3.9 % S Z5,498 up to 48 months* excludes freight ot $895 TOUR Km SPECIALISTS! | 2001 Pontiac Montana NEW!!!! FEB. 19-WOODBINE RACEWAY MAR. 15- CASINO NIAGARA CALL FOR DETAILS lUFfET MEAL PROVIDED BY CASINO HAMA WITH RAMA PLAYERS CARD j Includes: TRIP AND TAXES - Please Call to Reserve Your Seats j ALL PERSONS MUST DE I0 YEARS OR OLDER, WITH VALID PHOTO I.D, j CASINO RAMA DAY TRIPS 48 MONTH SwRlUttl 48 MONTH SuARilust S Z58" o«865' $4,800 down payment, $940 freight and $300 security deposit required PURCHASE FINANCING „ l Q% „„ $0 down payment, $940 freight and $425 security deposit required CASH PURCHASE >Z5,ti8 up to 60 months* excludes freight ol $940 3.1 Litre V6 175 HP Engine 1 4-Speed Automatic Transmission with Enhanced Traction System ■ 6-Passenger Seating with Quiet Interior 1 6-Way Power Driver's seat 1 Air Conditioning ' Power Door Locks/Windows • Cruise Control ☆☆☆☆☆ FIVE STAR SAFETY RATING. Pontiac Montana holds a 5-star driver scat rating In slde-lmpnct tests." • 3,4 Litre V6 185 HP Engine • 4-Speed Automatic Transmission • Air Conditioning • Power Door Locks/Wiiulows 'T' ■ ■ "'-'I', ■■'8; ' t.: ■ fi-V FRI., FEB. 16 MORN. SAT., FEB. 17 MORN. TOES., FEB, 20....MORN. WED., FEB. 21 AFT. | THUR., FEB.22 AFT. | FRI., FEB. 23 ....MORN.I I OSHAWA, WHITBY AND BOWMANVILLE PICKUPS 8 MIDTOWN DR. OSHAWA CALL 576-1357 <o 3 < o> For the latest information, drop by your local Pontiac • Buick • CMC Dealer, visit us at www.gmcanada.com or call 1-800-GM-DRIVE. Wo'd llko von to know moro: Como visit ua nt your local donlor, on our woballo at www.nmcnnndn.coin or call ua at 1-qoo-OM-DniVE. ttTosls conductor! by tho US National Highway and Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). At tOlloia apply to 2001 Pontiac Sunliro, Pontiac Grand Am, Buick Contuiy and I ^ItiSMonjona. ^Gonoml » ...:n it.-i ...zxnii.'fl (3MAC purchaso linnncu or lonso pay mont up to S500.00 Inclualvo ot taxes. Olfora basod on Sunflro Sodan SLXn7Z/Grnnd Am bL bodan e t72/Montann nWU I17A. Annual coat ot borrowing 1.0 ! V4.9Tô/5.4 o ;»/3.9% pur annum. Annual kilomotro limit ol 20,000 km, to^^por oxcosa kHomolio. 33 "LUCK GMC ill;,. ...II pay ll/X/ponlury Custom 1172/Montnnn Option to purchaso nt lonso ond Is S7.910MS0.807.30/S1U13.50/S12.401.40 (Sunfiio Sedan SLX I t///Grand Am plus oppllcnblo taxon. Othur lonso options ovnllnblo. T'FioIqIiI (as Indicated). licence, insuranco, P.P.b.A.. admin i Individual pilcon. tTho SmahiUasc monthly payment and thu GMAC purchaso finance rate am not ovnllnblo with ai Tim iiifinmnrn hntiA/nnn ttm mien lor tho SmafuLlasl/GMAC Purchaso Fiiianco of for and tho 'Cash Purchaso on mum. Annual kilomotro limit ol 20.000 km. SO. 12 nor oxcoss ki omoito. 2/Grand Am SL : Sedan R7X/Conluiy Custom FIZZ/Montana RWD F17A) 3,A., administration fous and taxes not Included. Dealers nro (too to sot /fad* IIIUIVIMUIU llllVVil. | mu uiuimujr r -- -- - • - Tho diiforonco botwoon tho pilco lor tho SmafuLlasl/GMAC Purcluioo Finança oiler and tho CtiJi, ... ---r- 'r7ô '/Vnr,o - /nmrui Am qp Rnrinn «.«^ r.SSSS'S'ÏSaswe depending on amount boirowed and down paymonVtrncfo. 'tf'Of fors apply as Indicated to select •.OC , and are not calculated on tho "Cash Purchaso Prico" shown, oiler la doomed under provincial disclosuro laws to bo n cost $ 10,000 nt 3.9% API 1, tho monthly payment le $226.34 for 40 months. -- r , r.7^» mav bo roouliod Monthly payment and cor.t of borrowing will vaiy depending on amount boirowed and down paymont/trndo. now or demonstrator models equipped an described, and to qualified retail customers In tho OntarioF 1 ' 0 K ll, ° ln l m,hfnS 0 A oiler which may not bo combined with other olfom Dealer cider or trade may bo nocoasaiy. See your Dueler for condilioiu and details. ...... . 001 iodation area only. Limited time